SEC and DOJ Official Insist on Lawsuit Against Nvidia
By Anthony Burr | TH3FUS3 Managing Editor
October 4, 2024 11:05 AM
Reading time: 1 minute, 45 seconds
TL;DR US officials are pressing the Supreme Court to allow a class action lawsuit against Nvidia. The lawsuit claims Nvidia misled investors about its revenue sources during 2017-2018. Accusations focus on downplaying crypto mining's impact.
Legal Battle Over Crypto Revenue
The U.S. Securities and Exchanges Commission and a DoJ official are urging the Supreme Court to allow a class action lawsuit against Nvidia to proceed.
The lawsuit claims Nvidia misled investors regarding the role of crypto mining in its 2017-2018 revenue growth.
U.S. Solicitor General Elizabeth Prelogar and SEC senior lawyer Theodore Weiman have advocated for the case's revival, citing detailed allegations in an amicus brief filing.
Support From Justice and SEC
The amicus brief from the Department of Justice and the Securities and Exchange Commission is a significant development. It supports investors' claims that Nvidia falsely attributed its revenue surge to gaming demand.
The brief alleges that Nvidia significantly understated the impact of crypto miners on its sales. This move followed the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals' decision to partially revive the case, which a lower court had dismissed.
Inside Information and Revelations
Firsthand accounts from former Nvidia employees have been instrumental in this lawsuit. One insider, referred to as FE 1, revealed that Nvidia maintained a global database to track GeForce GPU sales to crypto miners.
Another insider, FE 2, highlighted CEO Jensen Huang's involvement in meetings where the crypto influence on revenues was explicitly discussed. These insights suggest that Nvidia's leadership was aware of the impact of crypto but chose to downplay it publicly.
The authorities argue that Nvidia's leadership was well aware of crypto's influence on sales but chose to downplay it in public statements.
Economic Analysis and Implications
Expert analysis from Prysm Group has reinforced these allegations. It highlighted Nvidia's significant exposure to the cryptocurrency market, supported by internal documents and former employee accounts.
Nvidia's revenue dropped following the 2018 crypto crash, which the DOJ and SEC argue is evidence supporting that CEO Jensen Huang knowingly misled investors about Nvidia's crypto exposure.
Setting a Precedent for Transparency
The lawsuit underscores the necessity for corporate transparency in emerging markets, particularly concerning cryptocurrency. It sets a precedent for how risks in evolving markets should be disclosed to investors.
The outcome could influence corporate disclosure practices, ensuring investors receive accurate information about potential market influences.